May 9th, 2009 
Josh Dhani 
Posted in 
The Colts have now signed some new players in free agency and got some new guys from the draft. It brings me to the position battles. A lot of controversial picks but let’s see how it goes. These players will battle for the top, to win their position. Let’s go!
Quarterbacks: 1. Peyton Manning 2. Curtis Painter 3. Jim Sorgi 4. Chris Crane
The Battle: Second-String Quarterback
Who will be the second-stringer. It will never be Peyton Manning, the brain of the quarterbacks in the NFL. It will be between Painter, Sorgi, and Crane.
Painter has been flat-out great in his career, throwing for over 11,000 passing yards and 67 touchdowns. I see him as the second-stringer because he will be mentored greatly by the great Peyton Manning.
Although he might be backing Manning up for the next six years, by the time Manning retires, Painter is in.
Why? Because he has been behind Peyton for so long and will be about 27-31 years old by the time he is starter so he can be the man for the Colts for quite a while.
Then there is Jim Sorgi, who has only thrown for six touchdowns and one interception in his NFL career. He hasn’t been that good as a backup for Manning, and I can see why the Colts got those two other quarterbacks.
Sorgi will try to mentor and will probably be released during the season, but if he isn’t he will be at the third string.
Why? Because if he was in the Painter situation, he will be between 35-37 years old when he is starter. Indy won’t accept having him as starter for a year! That will just be unacceptable. It’s just too messed up that way.
Then there is Chris Crane battling. He won’t stand a chance. He has thrown for eleven touchdowns and 14 interceptions in his college career, which is pretty bad.
He had 10 touchdowns and 13 interceptions last year. He will need more time to improve. And that is why he is at the spot he is as we see in the depth chart.
Running Backs: 1. Joseph Addai 2. Donald Brown 3. Mike Hart 4. Lance Ball 5. Chad Simpson
Two Battles
1. Second String
Ah, the second string. It’ll be Donald Brown vs. Mike Hart for that spot. Mike Hart has one more year of experience but never did anything, only playing one game but only had one carry.
He was injured for the most part. But it will be Donald Brown because he was the first round pick for Indy and he looks to be the man to share the load with Joseph Addai. Hart looks to be something else.
But why Brown? Brown led the league, and it’s College Football of course, and was just spectacular. The Colts could have picked Chris Wells but Donald Brown fits the offense.
He will also be catching some balls, which Mike Hart might not be able to do. And that is why Brown will win this fight. But don’t feel too sorry for Hart, he has something, too!
2. Third String
The third string. The best third string back for the Colts I have seen is James Mungro. The Colts are looking for that next type of Mungro player. And that is where Mike Hart, Lance Ball, and Chad Simpson come in. Hart will win. Why?
Hart knows the Colts offense more than all of the running backs on the roster right now besides Joseph Addai. I also heard some rumors from many sites, including the Colts Corner, that the Colts will make Hart the third-down and goal line back. So he will get playing time.
Hart was also just made everyone dumbfounded of how great he was in Michigan. He was the Michigan Wolverines when he was there. Can he do it if he can be the next James Mungro? I told you, and you need to find out.
Why not Ball or Simpson? Those guys haven’t done much but have played more than Hart, no doubt about that. But these guys might get released.
Hart was never given a chance because of injury, but if he wasn’t, he would be having at least 100-300 yards last year.
Ball or Simpson might get released because it looks weird with five backs on the roster, and Colts won’t really use Ball or Simpson. Simpson might get released and Ball might be on the practice squad.
Let’s see how that turns out.
Wide Receivers: 1. Reggie Wayne 2. Anthony Gonzalez 3. Austin Collie 4. Roy Hall 5. Pierre Garcon 6. Taj Smith
Two Battles
1. Third String
Who will be the third-stringer. It’s between Collie and Hall. I say Collie. I heard some rumors on College Football Live that Austin Collie, from BYU, may be the next Marvin Harrison! Now imagine that!
Collie will be the slot because Collie does have the stats like he did last year: 106 catches for over 1,500 yards and 15 touchdowns. Career: 215 catches for 3,225 yards and 30 touchdowns. Man!
But it’s just not that. Collie looks like the Gonzalez of 2007. He can be very good at the slot and he did run a 4.50 at the combine.
Not much of the speed, but he is more of the possession kid. He can do a lot of things and he will be a Brandon Stokley type of kid in his first three years.
Roy Hall was close. He can’t because he didn’t have much playing time. He did run 4.40, faster than Collie, but he does have the hands Collie does. He could be close. It is going to be a huge battle.
He does have the size, very close to be 6’4″ and he is also 240 pounds. He is a big guy. He just needs to fix his hands more. But he will win in this spot.
2. Fourth String
This is where Hall, Garcon, and Smith compete. I say Hall because of his size advantage and he can catch the ball better than the the other two players. Hall will be that type of guy who will be a key receiver on occasional downs.
Garcon looks to be just a kick returner like he was last year. I say he is better off there and Taj Smith hasn’t done anything yet.
He will be a guy to add depth but we haven’t seen much from him. We’ll see how he does, but right now, Hall is in contention for the slot or this spot.
Tight Ends: Good as is.
Offensive Line: It won’t matter. No battles here. Everything is good as is.
RDE and LDE: No battles. It won’t matter. Everything is good as is.
Defensive Tackle: 1. Raheem Brock 2. Terrance Taylor 3. Fili Moala 4. Ed Johnson
Battle: The Two Starters
I said Brock and Taylor because these guys have what it takes. Last year, Brock was also left defensive end, but the Colts mostly put him at defensive tackle and he was just amazing and earned the starting spot.
Brock will be there and was pretty good last year by 14 games: 30 tackles and 3.5 sacks. I say Brock has what it takes and will stay there, no doubt.
Then who is the other guy. It’s between Taylor, Moala, and Johnson. I said Taylor because he is a much bigger and physical guy than Moala and Johnson. He also had better career stats in college than both of the two.
Even though he was picked in the fourth while Moala in the seconds, Taylor will get it. His size takes a big part and he will get there.
Linebackers: Nothing here. Good as is.
Cornerbacks, Safeties, Punters, and Kickers: Nothing here. Good as is.
So that is that. These battles are great. Let’s see how the Colts will progress to becoming a great team into next year. These battles will take a big part in the off-season and I hope you will enjoy it!
Comments? Suggestions? Any other battles I missed out on? Comment below and type out what you think!
Who wrote this? Is this just a blog because it’s structured worse than a fourth grader’s writing ability. Very good topic, but it’s complete dribble. I pray to god Mr. Dhani didn’t waste his money on any kind of journalism degree.
Why? (lol) Because this **** is terrible.
what can you do buddy. im only 13
wow… well, i’m sorry. that does make a world of defense. excellent effort Josh, but not quite journalism calliber yet. you have to see where i’m coming from in my assumption. lol. I however, am going to post my own break down of the battles. feel free to roast mine at your heart’s content.
http://www.football.com/forums/showthread.php?p=245932#post245932
Saying UDFA QB Chris Crane will challenge Jim Sorgi is outragous. Before you start to trash him, I might consider correcting your own training camp battles.Mike Hart will down Chad Simpson and Lance Ball easy.You spelled Amani Toomer wrong.Josh Thomas is not even on the Colts rooster anymore. Good job keeping up to date. Clint Session will battle Tyjuan Hagler for the SLB not those other guys. Freddie Keiaho has no competition.Seward is a special teamer. You act like you are some hot shot NFL insider, when you really lack the skill or knowledge to be anything greater than a post whore on some forum.Tim Jennings has no competition for nickelback. Good job showing you knowledge by adding T.J. Rushing into the nickelback section.
Kid you went from incorrectly saying i anticipate a battle between Chris Crane & Jim Sorgi to, saying “know something before you trash him.” In fact my exacty quote was “I have limited (no) knowledge of Chris Crane, but that alone could tell you he’s probably gonna have a hard time making the practice squad” . In no way is that trash talk. The simple fact is, regardless of how few passes Jim Sorgi has thrown in the NFL, only Peyton Manning knows the offense better. History will show you, the Colts will keep Sorgi. Since 1999 the Colts have had 8 different backup QB’s before Sorgi. Since 2004… one. Who? Jim Sorgi. Catch the net.
Next, I made no statement in regards to possible slot for neither of Hart, Ball, or Simpson. My only statement was if Hart could return healthy, he was.. and i quote, “the real deal” . It’s absorb to think he’ll come back from a knee reconstruction 100% in a year.
Next, who gives a shit how to spell Amani Toomer’s name. You must have googled that one to figure out who it was, because you obviously can’t read anyways. You could never distinguish his name correctly but yet NOT realize Josh Thomas’ name is a sentence which includes the words “last year.” I’ll clarify, if i were to say you saw a lot of Brett Favre in the NFL last year, you wouldn’t say “but Brett Favre doesn’t play anymore” . ****ing duh, idiot. That’s why in the context “last year” .
Here ya go, you’ll like this. You’re absolutely right. Freddie Keiaho could easily retain his job as weak-side linebacker. But, it is my firm belief, and others’ speculation that, Phillip Wheeler will start at weak-side in 2009. Seward is a player with a lot of potential and highly regarded by scouts. With less than productive rotation since replacing Cato June, Seward could be a big surprise.
Tim Jennings proved last year he has glaring fundemental challenges. It’s most likely that it was because of his larger role on the team. But, backups don’t live for ever my friend. Players like Dante Hughes were drafted for certain reasons, to replace “has-beens” .
And, for the record… I could name you the entire Colts Roster since 2005 off hand. So, don’t try and tell me i don’t know **** about the Colts… or football for that matter.
Take the time to read all of this one, you might learn something.
What gave you the idea that I think Sorgi will not make the roster. Why would the Colts re-sign Keiaho and Hagler if they thought that Seward or Wheeler would win the job. BTW, Seward is an inside linebacker, who the Colts signed for special teams help. Tim Jennings and Dante Hughes are on a whole different level, watch some football. “And, for the record… I could name you the entire Colts Roster since 2005 off hand.” So can I, and I doubt you could, and even if you could why would it matter.You still do not awnser my question about T.J. Rushings.
You are obviously uncapable of keeping an intelligent conversation with me. Thank you and please respond.
YEAH! GO BRYAN!
“Adam Seward was an inside lineback” ? Well, Cato June was a safety. So, fail. And, I think i’m the NFL insider? “… whom they signed for special teams help.” Who gave you this information? Caldwell or Bill Polian? Under the Dungy system, the best player played. No one is signed “just for special teams help.” They’re all signed for depth with some more than others being signed with any expectations.
Hagler has been a standout on special teams for at least 3 years. Just because he was re-signed doesn’t mean he’ll start? Neither does it mean the same for Keiaho. My statement about Keiaho is VERY bold, but I’m sticking to it. In regards to Hagler: Saying “why’d they resign him?” means he’ll start as much as saying “why’d they draft Phillip Wheeler?” Do a little research yourself. The idea of Wheeler having any kind of edge isn’t my own opinion. It’s someone else’s but i’m supporting it. Wheeler is a big project player as he was a D-end in college, he’s physical, and more athletic than Hagler.
Again, again, .. and again i’ll say it; I do not believe Freddie Keiaho will start in 2009. I even question whether he’ll stay with the team. He was barely re-signed, he was signed under undesclosed terms, there’s no clear cut fact he’ll start. Under what we have right now as the “Coyer Blueprint” he MIGHT fit the scheme, but tell me something that says he will?
Rushing was on IR for the entire 2008 season? What? I don’t get what the “question” is here? “Way to show your knowledge” ? He’s a player that has a good chance to make the cut, why shouldn’t he be included? You think you’ve got the answers, tell me how TJ Rushing is completely incapable of playing third on the roster? I’ll tell you, because the Colts will be very disappointed if it isn’t Daunte Hughes. He’s uncharecteristically slow, but he has fantastic ball skills. Jennings has average (or less) instincts. It’s been Jennings spot to lose. He’s obviously not good enough to start, how can you just say “he’s got the 3rd spot wrapped up” ? Because he doesn’t.
I’ll admit you (the brian guy) never said Sorgi wouldn’t make the roster, but the ‘tard that wrote this did.
So, for the last time…
T
H
E
R
E
Y
O
U
G
O
“Adam Seward was an inside lineback” ? Well, Cato June was a safety. So, fail. And, I think i’m the NFL insider? “… whom they signed for special teams help.” Who gave you this information? Caldwell or Bill Polian? Under the Dungy system, the best player played. No one is signed “just for special teams help.” They’re all signed for depth with some more than others being signed with any expectations.
Hagler has been a standout on special teams for at least 3 years. Just because he was re-signed doesn’t mean he’ll start? Neither does it mean the same for Keiaho. My statement about Keiaho is VERY bold, but I’m sticking to it. In regards to Hagler: Saying “why’d they resign him?” means he’ll start as much as saying “why’d they draft Phillip Wheeler?” Do a little research yourself. The idea of Wheeler having any kind of edge isn’t my own opinion. It’s someone else’s but i’m supporting it. Wheeler is a big project player as he was a D-end in college, he’s physical, and more athletic than Hagler.
Again, again, .. and again i’ll say it; I do not believe Freddie Keiaho will start in 2009. I question whether he’ll stay with the team. He was barely re-signed, he was signed under undesclosed terms, there’s no clear cut fact he’ll start. Under what we have right now as the “Coyer Blueprint” he MIGHT fit the scheme, but tell me something that says he will?
Rushing was on IR for the entire 2008 season? What? I don’t get what the “question” is here? “Way to show your knowledge” ? He’s a player that has a good chance to make the cut, why shouldn’t he be included? You think you’ve got the answers, tell me how TJ Rushing is completely incapable of playing third on the roster? I’ll tell you, because the Colts will be very disappointed if it isn’t Daunte Hughes. He’s uncharecteristically slow, but he has fantastic ball skills. Jennings has average (or less) instincts. It’s been Jennings spot to lose. He’s obviously not good enough to start, how can you just say “he’s got the 3rd spot wrapped up” ? Because he doesn’t.
I’ll admit you (the brian guy) never said Sorgi wouldn’t make the roster, but the ‘tard that wrote this did.
So, for the last time…
T
H
E
R
E
Y
O
U
G
O